Monte Selby was in third grade when he wrote his first song.
He performed the original “Gun Smoke Gus” while playing guitar in a talent show in his small town of Gage, Oklahoma, and took home a plastic trophy.
Selby, 64, now teaches music to elementary schoolers at Mabel I. Wilson School in Cumberland. On Monday, in between a dance circle and playing xylophone, he promised the third graders gathered on the carpet that this year, they would write a song together.
Outside his classroom hangs a photo of himself in third grade, the night he won the talent show.
The journey from his first song to the classroom of the Cumberland-North Yarmouth school district hasn’t been straightforward — from Grammy-winning songwriter to superintendent and everything in between — but there’s a refrain that always returns.
“My career path is very, very untypical, and kind of this unplanned adventure. But songwriting always shows up,” said Selby, who also lives in Cumberland.
Growing up, he started playing music with his brother, eventually forming a band and that played in Nashville shows and studios.
Simultaneously, he started his career teaching music and math. In the classroom, Selby said, he found his songwriting sparked by the hilarious things kids say. He’d play his original tunes about student antics for other teachers, who encouraged him to play at staff meetings and eventually education conferences and for other schools.
He wrote a song about not messing with the school secretary or the dress code. A song titled “Hormone Blues” went viral, with Selby getting international emails from teachers about it.
“I became a middle school principal, and I’ve always just said that’s like a songwriter’s playground. It’s just nuts,” said Selby.
As his trajectory as an educator grew, so did his sources of musical inspiration. He started writing songs collaboratively with kids, blending what they were learning in the classroom — animal habitats, for example — with expanding songwriting skills.

Selby estimates he’s written up to 1,000 songs, but it’s one song that got him a 2012 Grammy Award for best children’s album. He wrote a tune for English language learners that emphasized consonants and gradually sped up. Through a convoluted path, it was included on an album for kids about bullying. He didn’t know the album was nominated for a Grammy until he got the phone call that he had won.
“I actually love it that it wasn’t like I’m part of a group trying to write a song, trying to write a hit. I was trying to write something to help kids, and then it got its own life from there,” he said.
To this day students, with their internet-searching abilities, will ask him if it’s really true that he’s a Grammy winner. It’s too long a story to tell, he’ll reply. While Selby knows that a Grammy is his more widely recognizable accolade, it’s not his proudest achievement.
“I have some education awards that actually mean way more to me,” said Selby.
Selby went on to get his doctorate in education and was a professor of school leadership for nine years. He transitioned to freelance work as an education leader and collaborative songwriter in Kansas, eventually moving to Colorado with his family.
It was speaking at a conference in Maine and chatting with teachers from Mabel I. Wilson School that led him to move to Cumberland for his children’s final years of school. Seeking some semblance of normalcy during the COVID-19 pandemic, Selby switched from freelancing to move to Vinalhaven with his wife to become principal and eventually superintendent of the island school district. As the pandemic wound down and the Greely Middle School 6-8 principal position opened up, Selby and his wife moved back to Cumberland and he took that job in 2024.
As a Greely principal, Selby was an advocate for music and the arts, creating spaces where students could write songs and practice outside of the music program, and starting Friday morning open mics for students to perform in the school lobby.

MSAD 51 music teachers also felt the impact of Selby’s deep understanding of the importance of music education, helping them access professional development and emphasizing its significance in learning.
“It was the first time in my career where I actually felt completely seen,” said middle school music teacher Barry Saunders.
“There was a shift in perception, across administration, about the value of what we do down here. I think Monte was very effective in helping communicate that,” he said.
Saunders and eighth-grade volunteers are helping keep the middle school open mics going this year as Selby teaches in the elementary school. On Friday, a seventh grader was already practicing the new Taylor Swift song — which had been released just hours earlier — to play in the lobby, said Saunders.
Being a principal keeps you busy, and during two years leading the middle school, Selby’s guitar gathered some dust. In February, Selby decided to step down as principal to find more time for creativity and family.
“His whole songwriting career and all the work that he’s done with children about helping them become better learners through songwriting is …” Saunders laughs. “That’s magic!” He also joked that he tried to bribe Selby to stay on as an administrator. “That to me, is the elixir of what education needs more of.”
Continuing to teach music part time in the elementary school has struck the right balance, said Selby. With the kids of Cumberland and North Yarmouth continuing to say the funniest things, Selby now has the inspiration and time to write some more.
“I feel like a kid in a playground right now,” he said.

We invite you to add your comments. We encourage a thoughtful exchange of ideas and information on this website. By joining the conversation, you are agreeing to our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is found on our FAQs. You can update your screen name on the member's center.
Comments are managed by our staff during regular business hours Monday through Friday as well as limited hours on Saturday and Sunday. Comments held for moderation outside of those hours may take longer to approve.
Join the Conversation
Please sign into your Press Herald account to participate in conversations below. If you do not have an account, you can subscribe here. Questions? Please see our FAQs.