3 min read

A proposal before Portland City Council to bill certain nonprofits for payments in lieu of taxation, on a voluntary basis, would hurt organizations that do invaluable work for a city in need of that work. In its current form, this plan should not go ahead.

The text of the PILOT policy, which would only apply to organizations with property valued at more than $10 million, notes that “… any attempt to impose a legal or statutory requirement would face significant opposition and runs counter to the spirit of partnership between the city and its local institutions that a successful PILOT program would provide.”

Our city councilors must realize that even a voluntary scheme, like the one under consideration, would challenge a similar spirit of partnership.

The average nonprofit simply does not have this degree of flexibility. A number of well known and regarded nonprofits are urging the city not to proceed with the proposal, which offers some indication as to its weaknesses.

Even informal exploration by the City Council of means of ruling certain organizations out of the running for these payments — nonprofits engaged with housing, for example — acknowledges that the invitation to volunteer is a) supposed to work and b) that volunteering the cash will put the institutions that manage to volunteer it at a disadvantage.

The inconvenient reality is that a nonprofit is exempted from property tax for a reason; so that it may more reasonably accomplish its mission. Nonprofits’ operations tend to be contingent on the exemption. In a recent letter to the editor, Richard Farnsworth of Portland laid this out in clear terms.

Advertisement

“Nonprofits have their tax-exempt status given the understanding that they will provide services for the people of their towns. Most nonprofits are funded under contracts with government agencies that expect to see the benefits of their tax-exempt status in the bottom line of their contracts,” Farnsworth wrote.

“As a former manager of a nonprofit in Portland, I know that there is no way that agencies can afford the additional burden of the PILOT. And as a former state legislator, I can assure Mainers that the state won’t include those costs in their contracts with the agencies.”

The recent wave of revocations of nonprofit status by the city, met with considerable bewilderment, brings the difficulty with any such rearrangement in Portland into sharp focus. The implementation of a PILOT program seems unlikely to becalm the organizations that have already been assessed out of a status upon which their work as they know it depends.

To be clear: The financial challenges faced by the City of Portland are not to be minimized. This editorial board wholly supports the pursuit of new revenue streams — the newer, the more creative, the better — so long as they are arrived at thoughtfully, with careful attention to detail and rigorous consultation with relevant parties.

Any city under pressure to make ends meet is a city that leans heavily on nonprofits’ support, and Portland is no different. We probably shouldn’t be looking at robbing Peter to pay Paul.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.