Portland officials say the city will not invest millions of dollars in upgrades demanded by the federal government to keep a customs inspection operation at the city’s Ocean Gateway terminal, and that decision could end ferry service between Portland and Nova Scotia next year.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection says its agents currently work in temporary, inadequate facilities at the terminal and that upgrades were supposed to be part of reviving international ferry service four years ago. But those upgrades, which include building a new inspection building and adding other improvements, could cost Portland as much as $7 million, said Economic Development Director Greg Mitchell.
“We have been clear from Day One that we are not in a financial position to shoulder that expense,” Mitchell said in an interview Tuesday. The ferry’s unproven track record and questions about continued financial backing for the service from a provincial government in Canada made Portland officials reluctant to make the investment that customs officials are demanding.
“This background of uncertain subsidies and operators doesn’t inspire confidence,” Mitchell said.
Portland officials plan a formal response to Customs and Border Protection with possible paths forward, including a smaller investment by the city or a passenger pre-clearance facility in Canada.
“We have been in open communication with them, have held meetings with them this fall,” Mitchell said. “We are in the process of working on a more formal response to their request.”
CUSTOMS RUNS OUT OF PATIENCE
Customs and Border Protection agreed in 2014 to operate a two-year temporary screening facility at Ocean Gateway when ferry service between Portland and Yarmouth, Nova Scotia, resumed after a four-year hiatus.
The temporary facility was intended to give Portland time to see if the ferry service would be financially viable. Before starting operations, the city invested $150,000 in the Ocean Gateway terminal through a loan to Nova Star Cruises, which operated the ferry service at that time.
In August 2014, customs officials told Mark Amundsen, CEO of Nova Star Cruises, that the agency agreed to work at the terminal temporarily with the understanding that Nova Star would build permanent inspection facilities. The agency asked for improvements costing almost $4.7 million, including a $2 million inspection building, radiation scanning devices, a license-plate reader, closed-circuit television and new inspection booths. Portland officials estimate the federal requirements now would cost as much as $7 million.
Customs and Border Protection extended its acceptance of the temporary facility for another two years in 2016, after the Nova Scotia government canceled its contract with Nova Star Cruises, which had not met its passenger projections despite more than $40 million in subsidies. The company filed for bankruptcy in 2016.
Prince Edward Island-based Bay Ferries, which operated the Portland ferry service until 2009, was hired to replace Nova Star with a high-speed ferry, The Cat.
This summer, the federal agency’s patience appeared to have worn out. In a June 5 letter to City Manager Jon Jennings, Customs Area Port Director Keith Fleming said the agency would not provide inspection services after 2017 without a funded improvement plan.
“Despite our financial support and good-faith efforts to work with the city economic development director, over the last three years there has been no commitment or progress made toward bringing the existing facilities into compliance or an effort to build new facilities,” Fleming wrote.
Uncertainty over the ferry operators, different ships and the Nova Scotia government’s commitment to subsidize the service “did not allow the city to make any progress to make the multimillion-dollars of investment to support the CBP request,” Mitchell said Tuesday.
An investment of that size may also be out-of-scale for the ferry, especially when compared with the economic gains of increasing cruise ship traffic to Portland. In the past four years, cruise ships have paid $5.63 million in passenger fees to the city, compared with $672,250 from the Nova Scotia ferry, city records show. Cruise ship passengers are not required to undergo the CBP screening in port.
“We are trying to maximize revenue. We are going with what is working from a business standpoint,” Mitchell said.
No immediate solution to the problem is apparent, but Portland Mayor Ethan Strimling said the city has met with officials in Yarmouth to discuss a facility there where passengers and vehicles could receive pre-clearance from U.S. Customs so they could disembark freely in Portland. However, investing millions in a customs house in Portland is out of the question, Strimling said.
“It makes a lot more sense to have pre-clearance up there,” he said. “I think the international connection is a good connection, it is something I would like to see continue, but the price tag is too much.”
Bay Ferries carried 41,463 passengers in the season that ended Oct. 15, a 17 percent increase from 2016. The company expected to double the 35,500 passengers it had in 2016, but engine problems in June forced it to run at much slower speeds and cancel a quarter of its sailing days during the busiest point in the season.
“In this business we face serious regulatory issues all the time,” Bay Ferries CEO Mark MacDonald said in an interview Tuesday. “When we face them, we take them very seriously. Usually we solve them in some fashion.
“I really don’t want to speculate on how this is going to unfold,” he said.
FERRY INTEREST IN DIFFERENT HARBOR
Bay Ferries recently expressed interest in restarting service to Bar Harbor, using a redeveloped ferry terminal where it landed for 12 years until 2009, according to an October letter to the town from MacDonald. On Tuesday, MacDonald said interest in a different harbor was not directly related to the issues in Portland.
“We are not looking at Bar Harbor as a way to get around this problem. We are looking at the best, long-term sustainable solution for the ferry service,” MacDonald said.
Bay Ferries has a 10-year contract with the Nova Scotia provincial government and received $9.4 million in provincial subsidies in 2017.
In a response to emailed questions about the future of the government’s relationship with Bay Ferries, Nova Scotia Department of Transportation and Infrastructure Renewal spokesman Brian Taylor said Bay Ferries is an experienced operator that routinely navigates regulatory issues in the U.S. and Canada and was working to identify appropriate solutions to the customs issue in Portland.
“Any possible solution will take into account the best interests of Nova Scotians,” he said.
Peter McGuire can be contacted at 791-6325 or at:
pmcguire@pressherald.com
Twitter: PeteL_McGuire
Send questions/comments to the editors.
