FREEPORT — Airboat noise is generating an unusual number of complaints in town.
Town Manager Peter Joseph told the Town Council last week that there have recently been between 15 and 30 complaints about noise created by the craft.
The council also discussed what Chairwoman Sarah Tracy called a “new area of conflict” in the ongoing debate over the regulation of short-term rentals.
Tracy reminded councilors that the noise and rentals discussions were on the agenda for “transparency sake,” and weren’t to suggest that action would be taken on either one.
“We wanted to be sure the council is aware that these issues are ongoing and make sure we all have the same information and direct the issue in the way the council sees fit, should we decide we want to direct it,” she said.
After receiving concerns about airboat use, Joseph said town staff sought legal advice on whether the noise could be addressed by a local ordinance. They were referred to a 2005 opinion from the Maine Attorney General’s Office to the town of Brunswick, which says that municipalities in Maine are preempted by state law from regulating the operating of watercraft, including airboats.
The town can enforce state law regarding boat noise levels, which prohibits motorboats from exceeding a noise level of 90 decibels when stationary and 75 when operating, but is prohibited from adding or enforcing a local ordinance or regulation.
Town attorney Philip Saucier of Bernstein Shur believes the statute guidelines are still accurate, according to Joseph.
However, Joseph said the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife does not have a set of measurement standards, considers the decibel limit “unenforceable” and is seeking to address that.
“The statute exists, (but) the procedure to measure that … has never been (created) or used,” Joseph said. “If there was guidance in that statute, the town could enforce it.”
Resident Michael Ashby, who owns and operates an airboat for clamming in Freeport, said he felt targeted by the council’s discussion and that the council is trying to “get rid of him.”
Tracy replied that was false and said Joseph’s reports was simply a “general communication about an ongoing problem” that is not particular to anyone operator.
“It’s a general discussion of how or if we can regulate … sounds emitted from (watercraft),” she said. “We have received guidance to date … that we are not at liberty to regulate the noise within Freeport. … I want to correct that because that’s not fair.”
Joseph emphasized that if the state starts enforcing the law, it would apply to all watercraft, not just airboats.
SHORT-TERM RENTALS
Following what Tracy said were two recent instances about single-family dwellings in one of the town’s residential districts being used for commercial use, Code Enforcement Officer Nicholas Adams suggested how he would handle complaints.
Because the town does not have a short-term rental ordinance, Adams said there would be no zoning violation if a single-family dwelling is rented for any period of time if the family or group renting it were occupying the entire structure as a dwelling.
However, if the dwelling is rented to a commercial entity that is conducting business on the premises, such as car rentals, that could be a violation of town zoning and not permitted in the district. Adams noted the violations could be hard to enforce without solid evidence.
Jocelyn Van Saun can be contacted at 781-3661, ext. 183 or at:
jvansaun@theforecaster.net Twitter: JocelynVanSaun
Send questions/comments to the editors.
