AUGUSTA — A man convicted of kidnapping and sexually assaulting a young girl at knifepoint more than a decade ago was back in a courtroom Thursday, seeking to withdraw his guilty pleas based on a change in genetic evidence.
Albert F. Dumas Jr., 47, formerly of North Whitefield, had pleaded guilty in March 2007 to kidnapping the Augusta girl, whom he apparently chose at random. She was crossing Capitol Street in Augusta, not far from the former Buker Middle School, on Aug. 13, 2006.
He admitted to tying her wrists, forcing her into his car and repeatedly sexually assaulting her during a drive to his Whitefield home and then at his house. The prosecutor at the time, Deputy District Attorney Alan Kelley, told Justice Nancy Mills that Dumas threatened several times to kill her if she didn’t comply.
Dumas was arrested hours after driving the girl back to Augusta and releasing her. She had given police a detailed description of Dumas, including his tattoos and the license plate number and make of his vehicle. The girl picked Dumas’ photo from a lineup of convicted sex offenders. He was on the list for similar offenses with two other women.
He was sentenced to 70 years, with 30 suspended, and 12 years of probation.
His earliest release date from prison is Jan. 24, 2041, according to information on the state Department of Corrections website.
On Thursday, Deputy District Attorney Paul Cavanaugh represented the state, and attorney Seth Berner represented Dumas.
Dumas was the only witness called by Berner.
“Ms. Ames did inform me that they had DNA evidence against me that connected me to the crime.” Dumas testified, referring to Pamela Ames, who was his defense attorney at trial. “She didn’t tell me it was a low percentage that connected me to the crime.”
Dumas said he would have opted to go to trial had he known.
“If I would have known that they didn’t have conclusive DNA, I never would have pled guilty,” Dumas testified Thursday.
When asked about the other evidence, he said, “Most of it was circumstantial; some of it was wrong.”
Cavanaugh also called one witness, Catharine MacMillan, a forensic DNA analyst with the Maine State Police Crime Laboratory, who testified that she had analyzed samples taken from both Dumas and the victim.
She said she concluded that Dumas’ DNA profile matched that on a swab taken from the victim’s genitals and that a match to the girl’s DNA profile was found in a swab of human blood found on Dumas.
Berner said he had concerns about the chain of custody of the evidence, and Mills said Cavanaugh could bring witnesses to respond to that at a later date. In the meantime, the judge deferred ruling on the admissibility of some of the laboratory reports.
Betty Adams can be contacted at 621-5631 or at:
badams@centralmaine.com
Twitter: @betadams
Comments are not available on this story.
Send questions/comments to the editors.
